Craving those gorgeous grill marks and smoky flavors but stuck inside? I get it I used to think delicious grilled food was only possible with a big outdoor setup. Living in an apartment (or dealing with bad weather) always left me longing for that mouthwatering char.
But honestly, who has space for a bulky grill and the patience for endless cleanup? I was over bland, pan-fried meals, and I’m betting you are too. There had to be a smarter way to bring those bold, smoky flavors into the kitchen.
That’s when I dived headfirst into the world of grill pans. I tested everything from sleek options to total flops all in the pursuit of perfectly seared steaks, juicy burgers, and smoky veggies without stepping outside. Picture this: your kitchen sizzling with grill marks and irresistible aromas, even on a rainy Tuesday night.
After countless hours of cooking and research, I’ve narrowed it down to the 5 best grill pans that truly deliver. Whether you’re a seasoned chef or just love a simple grilled sandwich, these picks have got you covered. Say goodbye to grill envy and hello to indoor grilling perfection. Keep reading to find your next kitchen essential and achieve those bold, beautiful flavors you’ve been craving!
Our Tasting Experience
To determine the 5 best grill pans, we rigorously tested models from a wide range of brands. Our evaluation included grill pans from All-Clad, Lodge, GreenPan, and Le Creuset, among others. We assessed cast iron, nonstick, and square models to find the top performers for various needs.
After thorough testing, we selected the following 5 best grill pans based on specific strengths. The Lodge L8SGP3 Cast Iron Square Grill Pan stood out as the best pre-seasoned option with excellent draining capabilities. Its durable construction of steel and carbon alloy ensures it maintains heat well, making it ideal for near-restaurant-quality steaks. The high grates keep food above grease, though cleaning requires a scrub brush.
The Jean Patrique The Whatever Pan was chosen as the best for versatile cooking because it is lighter than cast iron and includes a lid, offering flexibility in meal preparation. The SENSARTE Nonstick Grill Pan earned its place as the best for all cooktops due to its versatile griddle design with pour spouts. Its square, large cooking surface and PFOA-free construction make it suitable for both indoor and outdoor grilling.
The Cuisinel Cast Iron Square Grill Pan excelled in cleaning and maintenance. It comes with a glass lid, pan scraper, and handle cover, making it convenient for grilling, frying, and sautéing on various heat sources. Lastly, the S·KITCHN Nonstick Grill Pan was recommended for nonstick performance. Its design is compatible with induction stovetops and includes a glass grilling pan for indoor use. The ceramic coating ensures easy cleaning.
Best selections
Best for Pre- seasoned Draining: Lodge L8SGP3 Cast Iron Square Grill Pan L8SGP3PLT
Best for Versatile Cooking: Jean-Patrique the Whatever Pan Cast Aluminum Griddle Pan JP1252_FBA
Best for All Cooktops: SENSARTE Nonstick Grill Grill-Granite
Best for Cleaning & Maintaining: Cuisinel Cast Iron Square Grill C10-SG-G
Best for Nonstick Performance: S·KITCHN Nonstick Grill Pan SJP33270401
Best for Pre- seasoned Draining
Lodge L8SGP3PLT
Heat Distribution: 9/10, Heat Retention: 10/10, Durability: 10/10, Ease of Cleaning: 7/10, Non-Stick Performance: 8/10, Design & Ergonomics: 8/10, Cooking Versatility: 9/10, Value for Money: 9/10
Material: Cast Iron, Handle: Sturdy Grip, Base: Thick, Square, Surface: Raised Ridges, Size: 10.5-inch, Weight: Heavy Duty, Compatibility: Stovetop, Oven, Cleaning: Hand Wash
The Lodge L8SGP3 is a versatile 10.5-inch pre-seasoned cast iron grill pan that excels in both indoor and outdoor grilling. Known for its superior heat retention and even distribution, this grill pan allows you to achieve perfect grill marks and a crispy sear on meats and vegetables. Cast iron’s ability to hold and evenly distribute heat ensures your food cooks consistently, providing delicious results every time. The raised ridges on the surface of the pan allow excess fat and grease to drain away, promoting healthier meals while still delivering that sought-after grilled flavor.
Pre-seasoned at the factory, the pan features a natural, non-stick surface that’s easy to clean and prevents rust. This pan can be used on a variety of cooking surfaces including stovetops, in the oven, or even over an open campfire, making it an incredibly versatile tool for cooking. The pan’s sturdy construction ensures longevity, giving you a dependable kitchen companion for years to come.
Although cast iron requires regular re-seasoning to maintain its non-stick quality, the Lodge L8SGP3 provides an authentic grilling experience, whether indoors or outdoors. Whether you’re cooking burgers, steaks, or vegetables, this pan will help you achieve that perfect grilled taste with ease.
.
Best for Versatile Cooking
Jean-Patrique JP1252_FBA
Heat Distribution: 8/10, Heat Retention: 7/10, Durability: 8/10, Ease of Cleaning: 9/10, Non-Stick Performance: 9/10, Design & Ergonomics: 8/10, Cooking Versatility: 9/10, Value for Money: 8/10
Material: Cast Aluminum, Handle: Ergonomic Grip, Base: Thin, Round, Surface: Smooth Finish, Size: 10.6-inch, Weight: Lightweight, Compatibility: Stovetop, Induction, Cleaning: Dishwasher Safe
The Jean Patrique the Whatever Pan is a 10.6-inch diameter cast aluminum griddle pan designed for versatile and efficient stovetop cooking. What sets this pan apart is its lighter weight compared to traditional cast iron, making it easier to handle without sacrificing performance. The pan heats up quickly and evenly, allowing for fast and consistent cooking. Whether you’re making pancakes, grilling sandwiches, or cooking other stovetop meals, this griddle pan provides excellent heat distribution for a uniform cook.
Equipped with a nonstick coating, this pan ensures easy food release and minimal cleanup after each use. The nonstick surface helps you cook with less oil, promoting healthier meals without compromising on flavor. The included lid traps moisture and heat, ensuring food cooks evenly and stays juicy. Whether you’re cooking delicate eggs or grilling meats, this feature allows for precise control over your dishes.
This pan’s design makes it an ideal choice for anyone looking for an easy-to-use, versatile griddle pan. It is perfect for a variety of cooking tasks and is suitable for all types of stovetops. Its lightweight construction makes storage easy and practical, and its nonstick surface ensures it stays in excellent condition with minimal care.
If you’re looking for a reliable and adaptable cooking tool, the Jean-Patrique JP1252_FBA The Whatever Pan is a top choice.
.
Best for All Cooktops
SENSARTE Grill-Granite
Heat Distribution: 8/10, Heat Retention: 7/10, Durability: 8/10, Ease of Cleaning: 9/10, Non-Stick Performance: 9/10, Design & Ergonomics: 7/10, Cooking Versatility: 8/10, Value for Money: 8/10
Material: Nonstick, Handle: Bakelite Grip, Base: Medium, Square, Surface: Smooth Finish, Size: 9.5-inch, Weight: Lightweight, Compatibility: All Stovetops, Cleaning: Hand Wash
The SENSARTE Nonstick Grill Pan is a sleek 9.5-inch square grill pan designed to bring the essence of grilling right to your stovetop and easily set with all type of cooktops. Ideal for indoor grilling, this pan features a high-quality nonstick coating that allows food to release easily, making cleanup a breeze. The PFOA-free surface ensures that no harmful chemicals are used in the coating, providing a safer, healthier cooking experience. The pan also comes with pour spouts, making it easier to drain excess fat or liquids, so you can enjoy healthier meals without sacrificing flavor.
What makes this pan stand out is its versatility. It works with all stovetops, including electric, gas, and induction, making it a perfect addition to any kitchen, regardless of your cooking surface. The durable construction ensures it holds up over time and provides consistent results, whether you’re cooking chicken, vegetables, or steaks. The raised ridges on the pan create those signature grill marks while draining away excess fat, making your food both flavorful and healthier.
In addition to its functionality, this grill pan’s granite-like finish gives it a stylish, modern look that will complement any kitchen. If you’re looking for an affordable, easy-to-use pan for indoor grilling, the SENSARTE Grill-Granite is a great option that delivers high performance with minimal effort.
Best for Cleaning & Maintaining
Cuisinel C10-SG-G
Heat Distribution: 9/10, Heat Retention: 9/10, Durability: 10/10, Ease of Cleaning: 7/10, Non-Stick Performance: 8/10, Design & Ergonomics: 8/10, Cooking Versatility: 9/10, Value for Money: 9/10
Material: Cast Iron, Handle: Protective Cover, Base: Thick, Square, Surface: Raised Ridges, Size: 10.5-inch, Weight: Heavy Duty, Compatibility: Stovetop, Oven, Cleaning: Hand Wash
The Cuisinel Cast Iron Square Grill Pan Set is a comprehensive and durable solution with easy cleaning maintenance for all your grilling needs. This set includes a 10.5-inch pre-seasoned cast iron grill pan, a glass lid, a pan scraper, and a handle cover, giving you everything you need for a successful cooking experience. Cast iron’s ability to distribute heat evenly ensures that your food is cooked to perfection every time, while the pre-seasoned surface helps create a natural, non-stick cooking environment. The raised ridges in the pan allow fat to drain away, promoting healthier meals without sacrificing flavor.
The included glass lid allows you to trap moisture and heat, keeping your food tender and juicy while cooking. The lid also helps maintain consistent cooking temperatures, ensuring that your food is cooked evenly. The pan scraper is a thoughtful addition to this set, making cleanup easy after use, while the handle cover provides protection from the hot handle, allowing for safe handling.
Whether you’re grilling, frying, or sautéing, this versatile pan set is perfect for use both indoors and outdoors. It’s compatible with all stovetops, and its long-lasting durability ensures it will become a staple in your kitchen for years to come. The Cuisinel C10-SG-G Grill Pan Set is ideal for anyone who enjoys cooking and wants a reliable, efficient, and easy-to-use pan set.
Best for Nonstick Performance
S·KITCHN SJP33270401
Heat Distribution: 8/10, Heat Retention: 7/10, Durability: 8/10, Ease of Cleaning: 9/10, Non-Stick Performance: 9/10, Design & Ergonomics: 8/10, Cooking Versatility: 8/10, Value for Money: 8/10
Material: Nonstick, Handle: Glass Lid, Base: Medium, Square, Surface: Smooth Finish, Size: 10.5-inch, Weight: Moderate, Compatibility: Induction, Gas, Cleaning: Dishwasher Safe
The S·KITCHN Nonstick Grill Pan is a fantastic option for anyone looking to bring the joy of grilling with Nonstick Performance to their kitchen, especially for those with induction cooktops. This nonstick grill pan is designed for easy food release and effortless cleanup, making it ideal for indoor cooking. The pan’s nonstick surface helps to reduce the need for excess oil, promoting healthier meals while ensuring that food doesn’t stick to the pan. This makes it perfect for grilling a variety of dishes such as chicken, vegetables, and even fish.
Equipped with a glass lid, the pan allows you to monitor your food while it cooks, preventing overcooking or burning. The lid also helps to retain moisture and heat, ensuring that food is cooked evenly and remains juicy. This grill pan is suitable for use on gas ranges, induction cooktops, and other stovetops, making it a versatile addition to any kitchen.
In addition to its functionality, the S·KITCHN Nonstick Grill Pan boasts a durable construction that ensures long-lasting performance. Its sleek design and practical features make it a great choice for anyone who enjoys grilling indoors.
Whether you’re looking for a pan for grilling or general stovetop cooking, the S·KITCHN SJP33270401 Nonstick Grill Pan will meet your needs with ease.
Buying Guide
Choosing the right grill pan can elevate your indoor cooking, providing those coveted grill marks and a healthier cooking experience. Here’s what to consider:
Material
Cast iron reigns supreme for heat retention and even cooking, essential for searing. Aluminum grill pans offer a lighter alternative with rapid heating. Consider a bonded steel base for even heat distribution.
Size and Shape
Grill pans typically range from 10 to 12 inches. Larger pans accommodate more food but require more storage space. Square, rectangular, or round shapes are available; choose based on your stovetop and cooking preferences. Dual-sided grill pans with a sear side offer versatility for those with limited space.
Handles
Look for a long handle that stays cool, though it may add weight. A helper handle can aid in lifting heavy, fully-loaded pans. Some grill pans have removable handles for oven use.
Non-Stick Coating
Opt for a PFOA-free non-stick coating for easy food release and cleanup. Die-cast aluminum pans are sturdy and often nonstick without a coating, allowing for high heat without fumes. Note that non-stick coatings may scratch over time.
Versatility
Consider oven-safe grill pans for expanded cooking options. Some are compatible with all cooktops, including induction.
Other Features
Raised lines create grill marks and drain excess fat. Pour spouts simplify serving. Look for models with features like glass lids or included cleaning tools.
FAQs
Are grill pans worth the investment?
Yes! Grill pans can enhance your indoor cooking by providing those desirable grill marks and allowing for healthier cooking methods. If you’re craving that grilled flavor year-round and don’t have outdoor space, a high-quality grill pan is a great investment for your kitchen.
How do I properly clean my grill pan?
Cleaning a grill pan depends on the material. For cast iron, avoid soap unless necessary and use a stiff brush with hot water. For non-stick pans, soak in warm, soapy water to loosen stuck food and avoid harsh scrubbers. Make sure to clean your pan immediately after use to prevent food from hardening and making cleanup more difficult.
Will my grill pan work with my induction cooktop?
To use a grill pan on an induction cooktop, it must be magnetic. Cast iron pans typically work with induction. For other materials, check by placing a magnet on the bottom of the pan; if it sticks firmly, it’s induction-compatible. Always confirm induction compatibility in the product description before purchasing.
Final Thought
Looking for the perfect grill pan to elevate your cooking? Choosing the best one depends on your cooking style, budget, and priorities. All 5 options offer distinct advantages. The Lodge L8SGP3 cast iron grill pan delivers classic grilling performance with excellent heat retention and a pre-seasoned surface. The Jean Patrique Whatever Pan offers a lighter, nonstick alternative for everyday cooking versatility. The SENSARTE Nonstick Grill Pan provides a PFOA-free nonstick surface and compatibility with all stovetops. The Cuisinel Cast Iron Grill Pan set offers a complete grilling package with a lid, scraper, and handle cover. The S·KITCHN Nonstick Grill Pan is a good choice for those needing an induction-compatible option.While each pan has its merits, I would highly recommend the Lodge L8SGP3 for its superior heat retention and classic grilling flavor, the Jean Patrique Whatever Pan for its lightweight versatility and easy cleanup, and the SENSARTE Nonstick Grill Pan for its health-conscious nonstick surface and compatibility with all cooktops. These three offer a great balance of performance, convenience, and versatility for most home cooks. Consider your specific needs from searing steaks to making pancakes to choose the perfect grill pan for your kitchen.
Leave a Reply